Verdict
you need code for more platforms than TradingView and MetaTrader 5 (it also lists MQL4, cTrader, NinjaTrader and thinkorswim), you want a visual no-code Pine editor, or you'd use its screeners, finance agent and optimizer. Plans are one-time payments from $99.
you want a monthly option or a lower one-time price ($49), MQL5 Expert Advisors compiled in MetaEditor before delivery, Python crypto bots, and a 7-day money-back guarantee on an unused first purchase.
At a glance
| Aspect | Edgoro | Pineify |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $29/month or $49 once (Lifetime). MT5 and Python bots are an option: +$25 at checkout or $49 later | One-time plans: Plus $99, Advanced $149, Expert $259 (November prices; list $219 and $369), with monthly AI credits |
| Pine Script v6 | Yes, always v6 | Yes, v6 by default |
| MT5 / MQL5 | Yes, MQL5 Expert Advisors (bots option). No MQL4 | Yes, plus MQL4, cTrader C#, NinjaScript and thinkScript |
| Python bots | Yes, ccxt bots for Binance, Bybit and OKX (bots option) | Not listed |
| Compile check | MQL5 compiled in MetaEditor and Python checked with py_compile; Pine Script checked by Edgoro Pine Check, our own v6 checker (not TradingView's compiler). Up to 2 automatic fixes | Says its agent validates syntax and fixes errors before showing the code |
| Chart analysis | Yes, from a screenshot of any chart, in both plans | Yes: 2, 5 or 20 analyses a day depending on the plan |
| Backtesting | Pine strategies ready for TradingView's Strategy Tester; Backtest Lab option ($9/month) on crypto history | Backtest Deep Report and Strategy Optimizer extension (Advanced and Expert) |
| Free option | Free Pine Script generator (3 scripts a month, no account), error fixer, strategy builder, 33 calculators and an indicator library. No free tier for the builder | Free tools on its site; the AI plans are paid |
| Refunds | 7-day money-back guarantee on an unused first purchase | No refunds once a purchase is completed |
What each tool is
Pineify is a broad trading-code toolkit. Its AI coding agent writes Pine Script v6 by default and, according to its FAQ, also MQL4, MQL5, cTrader C#, NinjaTrader 8 NinjaScript and thinkorswim thinkScript. Next to the agent it offers a visual Pine Script editor, AI chart analysis, and on higher plans a finance agent, a stock and options picker, a strategy optimizer extension, a trading journal and a market screener. Plans are paid once and include AI credits every month.
Edgoro turns a plain-English description into a TradingView indicator or strategy in Pine Script v6, and analyses chart screenshots. MetaTrader 5 Expert Advisors in MQL5 and Python crypto bots are an option on top of a plan; each EA is compiled in MetaEditor before you get it, with up to two automatic fixes. It launched in November 2026 and is built by a small company in France. Plans are Pro Monthly at $29 a month or Lifetime at $49 once.
Where Pineify is stronger
- More platforms. If you trade on cTrader, NinjaTrader, thinkorswim or MetaTrader 4, Pineify lists them; Edgoro doesn't write code for any of them.
- A visual editor. You can build Pine indicators and strategies by picking from 235+ indicators, without writing a prompt.
- A wider toolset. Screeners, options flow, analyst ratings, a journal and an optimizer come with the higher plans. Edgoro has none of these.
- A longer track record. Pineify's TradingView account dates from November 2023; Edgoro launched in November 2026.
- Pine validation. Pineify says its agent validates and fixes syntax before you see the code. Edgoro runs its own v6 checker, Edgoro Pine Check, and fixes what it finds, but it isn't TradingView's compiler: the Pine Editor has the final word, and you paste any error back for a fix.
Where Edgoro is different
- Price and billing. Edgoro costs $29 a month or $49 once, against Pineify's one-time plans from $99. Pineify's plans have no monthly option.
- MetaTrader 5 with a real compile. Each Expert Advisor is compiled in MetaEditor, MetaTrader 5's own compiler, and compiler errors go back to the AI automatically, up to two fixes per conversation.
- Python crypto bots. Edgoro writes ccxt bots for Binance, Bybit and OKX that start in paper mode. Pineify doesn't list Python.
- Refunds. Edgoro refunds a first purchase in full within 7 days if the account hasn't been used. Pineify's refund policy says it doesn't refund completed purchases.
- Chart analysis in both plans, from a screenshot of any platform.
Pricing side by side
Pineify (pricing section of its homepage, 6 November 2026): Plus $99, Advanced $149 (list $219) and Expert $259 (list $369), each paid once. Plus includes 500 AI credits a month, 100 "Pine Model" messages every five hours and 2 chart analyses a day; Advanced doubles the credits and adds the finance agent, optimizer, backtest report and journal; Expert adds 3,000 monthly credits, 10,000 credits that don't expire and the market screener. The discounted prices are marked as available all November.
Edgoro: Pro Monthly $29 a month or Lifetime $49 once, both with Pine Script indicators and strategies and chart analysis. Trading bots (MT5 and Python) are one option at +$25 at checkout or $49 later, so Lifetime with bots comes to $74. Backtest Lab, Copilot and the Prop Firm Pack are separate options.
Try before you decide
Edgoro's free Pine Script generator writes 3 scripts a month without an account, with the same instructions as the paid builder. Whichever tool you pick, paste the script into TradingView, check that it compiles and that signals look right on several charts, and test any bot on a demo account first.
Frequently asked questions
Is Edgoro cheaper than Pineify?
On the entry price, yes: Edgoro Lifetime is $49 once and Pro Monthly $29 a month, while Pineify's cheapest plan was $99 once on 6 November 2026. Pineify's higher plans include tools Edgoro doesn't offer, such as screeners and a finance agent, so compare the features you'll actually use. MT5 and Python bots on Edgoro are an option at +$25 at checkout or $49 later.
Does Pineify write MT5 Expert Advisors?
Yes. Its coding agent lists MQL5 and MQL4, along with cTrader, NinjaTrader and thinkorswim. Edgoro writes MQL5 for MetaTrader 5 only, and compiles each EA in MetaEditor before you get it.
Which one checks that the code compiles?
Pineify says its agent validates syntax and fixes errors before showing code. Edgoro compiles MQL5 in MetaEditor and checks Python with py_compile, with up to two automatic fixes. Pine Script goes through Edgoro Pine Check, its own v6 checker, which also fixes problems automatically; it isn't TradingView's compiler, so the Pine Editor remains the final check.
Can I get a refund?
Pineify's refund policy says it doesn't offer refunds once a purchase is completed. Edgoro refunds a first purchase in full within 7 days if the account hasn't been used yet.
Sources
- Pineify homepage: pricing section and FAQ · checked on
- Pineify Pine Script AI Coding Agent · checked on
- Pineify refund policy · checked on
- Pineify on TradingView (account created November 2023) · checked on
- Edgoro pricing · checked on
- Edgoro refund policy · checked on
- Edgoro Pine Script generator: what it writes and its limits · checked on
- Edgoro MT5 Expert Advisor generator: compile check · checked on
Product names belong to their owners and are used only to identify the products compared. Spotted something out of date? Write to support@edgoro.com and we'll correct it. Trading involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for every investor. Edgoro is a software tool, not a broker or financial adviser: nothing it produces is investment advice, and past or backtested performance does not guarantee future results.