Verdict
MetaEditor's AI Assistant and MQL5 Wizard: built into MetaTrader 5, which is free to download. The Assistant runs on a free MQL5 lite model by default and can create EAs, compile them and run tests.
fxDreema: visual blocks for MT4 and MT5, free for small projects, paid periods from €27 that never renew automatically.
EA Builder: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and TradeStation, $97 once for lifetime access, free for indicators.
Pineify: MQL5 plus MQL4, Pine Script, cTrader, NinjaTrader and thinkorswim, one-time plans from $99.
StrategyQuant X: genetic programming and machine learning, Monte Carlo and walk-forward tests, export to MT4, MT5 and four other platforms. From $1,290, with a 14-day free trial.
Edgoro: complete MQL5 Expert Advisors compiled in MetaEditor before delivery, plus Pine Script v6 and Python crypto bots. $29 a month or $49 once, with the bots option at +$25 at checkout or $49 later.
At a glance
| Tool | Pricing | How you build | Platforms | AI | Compile check | Backtesting | Free option | Refunds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EA Builder | $97 once, lifetime access | Point-and-click web app | MT4, MT5, TradeStation | Not mentioned | Not stated | Not described (its tutorial videos cover it) | Free for indicators | Not stated |
| fxDreema | €27 for 1 month to €133 for 12 months, no auto-renewal | Visual blocks | MT4, MT5 | Not mentioned | Not stated | MetaTrader's Strategy Tester, which it tells you to use | Small projects: 10 block connections, 100 blocks | You can ask; may not be granted |
| MetaEditor AI Assistant and MQL5 Wizard | Free with MetaTrader 5 | AI chat, or a wizard of ready-made modules | MT5 (its AI examples include MQL4 to MQL5) | Yes: free MQL5 lite model by default, other providers optional | Yes: MetaEditor is MT5's compiler, and the Assistant can compile | Strategy Tester; the Assistant can run tests and optimizations | Free (MQL5.community sign-in for the Assistant) | Not applicable |
| Pineify | $99–$259 once; says annual subscriptions are coming | AI coding agent (chat) | MQL5, MQL4, Pine Script, cTrader, NinjaTrader, thinkorswim | Yes | Says its MQL5 is error-free; its compile loop is described for Pine Script | Not described for MT5 | Free tools; AI plans paid | None after purchase |
| StrategyQuant X | $1,290–$2,900 once, or 12 monthly instalments | Searches entry and exit rules against your criteria | MT4, MT5, NinjaTrader, TradeStation, MultiCharts, JForex | Machine learning and genetic programming; 300 AI credits on trial | Not stated | Built in, with Monte Carlo and walk-forward tests | 14-day full trial | Generally non-refundable |
| Edgoro (our product) | $29/month or $49 once; bots +$25 at checkout or $49 later | Plain-English chat | MT5 (MQL5 only); also Pine Script v6 and Python | Yes | Compiled in MetaEditor before delivery, up to 5 automatic fixes in a row | MetaTrader 5's Strategy Tester | No free tier for EAs | 7 days on an unused first purchase |
Every fact was read on the tool's own website on 16 November 2026. "Not stated" or "Not mentioned" means the site didn't say, not that the feature is missing; "Says" marks a vendor claim we didn't test.
How we compared
We read each tool's own website on 16 November 2026: pricing, platforms, how you build an Expert Advisor, whether AI is involved, compile checks, backtesting, free options and refunds. We did not score the tools or test the quality of the code they produce, and there are no ratings on this page. Where a vendor makes a claim we couldn't check, we write it as a claim. A tool whose site blocked our automated check that day is listed under "Not covered here" instead of being described from memory. Edgoro is our product; it is in the list, last, with the same columns as everyone else. The same method is behind our roundup of AI Pine Script generators.
The tools, and what each is best for
EA Builder
A web app for building indicators and strategies "without programming": you set the conditions with the mouse and download the code for MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 or TradeStation. Its site says the code is human-readable, commented and kept in a single file. Indicators are free; the Unlimited version costs $97 once for lifetime access, sold through ClickBank. Its homepage doesn't mention AI, a compile step or a refund policy. Stronger than Edgoro on: MetaTrader 4 and TradeStation, a free indicator builder, and no prompt to write. Best for: point-and-click EAs on several platforms, paid once.
fxDreema
A visual builder: you connect blocks with the mouse to make Expert Advisors and scripts for MetaTrader 4 and 5, including martingale, trailing stops and custom indicators. It is free for small projects (up to 10 connections between blocks, which you need to export a file, 100 blocks per project and 30 projects). The Full plan is a one-time payment per period, from €27 for one month to €133 for twelve, and never renews automatically; paid members also get a converter from MQL4 to MQL5. Its site doesn't mention AI. Stronger than Edgoro on: every condition is a block you can see and move, MetaTrader 4 support, a free tier and the converter. Best for: traders who want to see and edit the logic visually. Edgoro vs fxDreema.
MetaEditor's AI Assistant and MQL5 Wizard (MetaQuotes)
MetaEditor, MetaTrader 5's development environment, has a built-in AI Assistant. MetaQuotes' help says it can create Expert Advisors, indicators and scripts, analyse or modify existing code, compile programs and run tests and optimizations. MQL4-to-MQL5 conversion is among its examples. It runs on a free MQL5 lite model by default, needs you to sign in to an MQL5.community account, and can be set up to use a model from another provider; through MCP, compatible external AI apps and agents can work with MetaEditor too. The older MQL5 Wizard builds an EA from modules you choose (signals, money management, trailing stop) without programming. MetaTrader 5 is free to download. Stronger than Edgoro on: it costs nothing, works inside the platform where the EA runs, keeps the compiler and the Strategy Tester in the same window, and lets you choose the AI model. Best for: MT5 traders who want to stay in MetaTrader and pay nothing.
Pineify
An AI coding agent best known for Pine Script that also writes MQL5 for MetaTrader 5 and, according to its FAQ, MQL4, cTrader C#, NinjaScript and thinkScript. It says it generates "error-free MQL5 code"; the compile-and-fix loop its agent page details is written about Pine Script. Plans are paid once: Plus $99, Advanced $149 and Expert $259 (Black Friday prices; list $219 and $369), with monthly AI credits. Its site says it is "moving to annual subscriptions soon", and its refund policy rules out refunds after a purchase. Stronger than Edgoro on: MQL4, cTrader and NinjaTrader from the same chat, and more tools for TradingView users. Best for: traders who code for several platforms. Edgoro vs Pineify.
StrategyQuant X
A desktop platform for Windows, Mac and Linux that generates strategies with genetic programming and machine learning. Rather than writing an EA from a description, its builder tests combinations of entry and exit rules against criteria you set, such as net profit or Sharpe ratio, then runs robustness checks (Monte Carlo, walk-forward, parameter permutations). It exports full source code to MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 (hedging and netting), NinjaTrader, TradeStation, MultiCharts and JForex. Licences are lifetime: Starter $1,290, Professional $1,490, Ultimate $2,900, or 12 monthly instalments from $129 to $290. There is a 14-day full trial and a one-time trial of 300 AI credits; purchases are "generally non-refundable". Stronger than Edgoro on: finding and stress-testing strategies at scale, and six export platforms. Best for: systematic traders who want to generate and test many strategies.
Edgoro (our product)
Describe the market, entry, stop, risk per trade and trading hours in plain English, and Edgoro writes a complete MQL5 Expert Advisor with the risk controls as inputs. It compiles the EA in MetaEditor before you get it and sends any compiler errors back to the AI, up to 5 automatic fixes in a row. The same account writes Pine Script v6 for TradingView and, with the same option, Python crypto bots. Expert Advisors are part of the trading bots option on top of a plan: $29 a month or $49 once, plus +$25 at checkout or $49 later, so Lifetime with bots comes to $74 once. There is a 7-day money-back guarantee on an unused first purchase. Limits: MetaTrader 5 only (no MQL4), no backtester of its own for MT5, no free tier for EAs, and a short track record (launched in November 2026). Best for: plain English to a compiled MQL5 EA, next to TradingView and crypto code. How the MT5 EA generator works.
If you use a general-purpose AI assistant
General-purpose AI assistants such as Claude write MQL5 when you ask. You then compile the code in MetaEditor yourself, paste any errors back, and check that it really is MQL5 for MetaTrader 5, not MQL4 or C++ habits that MQL5 rejects. MetaEditor's own AI Assistant can also be pointed at a model from another provider, which keeps the compiler one click away.
What to check before you pay
- MQL4 or MQL5. MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 use different languages. Make sure the tool writes for the terminal your broker gives you.
- Who compiles it. The result that counts is MetaEditor's: 0 errors. Find out whether the tool compiles before delivery or leaves it to you.
- The source code. Make sure you get the .mq5 source, not only a compiled file, so you or a developer can read and change it.
- Risk controls. Risk per trade, a stop on every order, a daily loss limit, spread and session filters. Our MQL5 Expert Advisor risk checklist lists what to look for.
- Backtest, then demo. Use the Strategy Tester with real ticks, then weeks on a demo account. A generator that tries thousands of rule sets can find one that fits the past by chance: see backtesting mistakes that inflate results.
- Billing and refunds. On 16 November 2026 these went from free (MetaEditor) and paid periods (fxDreema) to lifetime licences (EA Builder, Pineify, StrategyQuant X), and from no refunds (Pineify) to 7 days on an unused first purchase (Edgoro).
Not covered here
Myfxbook Strategy AI, an MT5 EA generator we compared on 6 November 2026, blocked our automated check on 16 November, so it isn't in the table; Edgoro vs Myfxbook Strategy AI shows its plans as read on 6 November. Other EA builders appear in search results too; this list covers the ones we could verify on the day. Building for TradingView instead? See the best AI Pine Script generators. For crypto exchanges, see the best AI crypto trading bot generators.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best AI for MQL5?
There's no single best. MetaEditor's built-in AI Assistant is free and sits next to the compiler; Pineify writes MQL5 alongside five other platforms; Edgoro (our product) writes a complete EA from plain English and compiles it in MetaEditor before you get it; general-purpose assistants such as Claude write MQL5 too, but you compile it yourself. Whatever you use, check for 0 errors in MetaEditor and test on demo.
Is there a free AI MT5 EA generator?
MetaEditor's AI Assistant runs on a free MQL5 lite model by default (you sign in to an MQL5.community account), and the MQL5 Wizard is built into MetaTrader 5, which is free to download. fxDreema is free for small projects, EA Builder is free for indicators only, and StrategyQuant X has a 14-day trial. Edgoro has no free tier for Expert Advisors.
Which tools compile the EA before you get it?
MetaEditor is MetaTrader 5's compiler, and MetaQuotes says its AI Assistant can compile programs. Edgoro compiles every EA in MetaEditor before delivery, with up to 5 automatic fixes in a row. Pineify says its MQL5 code is error-free. EA Builder, fxDreema and StrategyQuant X don't describe a compile step on the pages we read.
Which of these tools also work with MetaTrader 4?
fxDreema, EA Builder, Pineify and StrategyQuant X list MetaTrader 4 as well as 5. MetaQuotes lists turning an MQL4 EA into MQL5 among its AI examples, and fxDreema has an MQL4-to-MQL5 converter for paid members. Edgoro writes MQL5 for MetaTrader 5 only.
Can an AI Expert Advisor generator make a profitable EA?
None of these tools can promise that. A clean compile proves the code builds, not that the strategy works. Run any EA in the Strategy Tester, then on a demo account for several weeks, before real money.
Sources
- EA Builder homepage: platforms, free version and price · checked on
- fxDreema homepage · checked on
- fxDreema purchase plans · checked on
- fxDreema MQL4 to MQL5 converter · checked on
- MetaEditor help: MCP and AI (AI Assistant) · checked on
- MetaTrader 5: MQL5 Wizard · checked on
- MetaTrader 5 download · checked on
- Pineify homepage: pricing and FAQ · checked on
- Pineify AI Coding Agent · checked on
- Pineify refund policy · checked on
- StrategyQuant X homepage · checked on
- StrategyQuant X features: export platforms · checked on
- StrategyQuant X pricing · checked on
- Edgoro pricing · checked on
- Edgoro refund policy · checked on
- Edgoro MT5 Expert Advisor generator: compile check · checked on
Product names belong to their owners and are used only to identify the products compared. Spotted something out of date? Write to support@edgoro.com and we'll correct it. Trading involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for every investor. Edgoro is a software tool, not a broker or financial adviser: nothing it produces is investment advice, and past or backtested performance does not guarantee future results.